Perspectives/Feedback expiry Subscribe to Perspectives

Your Microsoft feedback expires after 15 months.

Post an idea on Microsoft's Feedback portal, collect votes, wait. Fifteen months later the idea is gone, with its votes and comments. Nobody tells you. The only ideas that outlive the clock are the ones a Microsoft employee has curated into a Collection, and that has nearly stopped happening.

110 122ideas on the portal on 16 November 2026
≈222expire every day. That's about 9 an hour.
9 August 2025where the surviving individual ideas begin
feedbackportal.microsoft.com / Planner

Need Full Graph API Support for Premium Plans

20 days

until this idea is due to expire on or about 7 December 2026. It had 89 votes at the last observation. Directly checked on 16 November 2026. Its predecessor in the Microsoft Graph forum, posted in October 2024 with roughly 300 votes, already went the same way.

The secret expiration rule

The Learn article on how to give feedback to Microsoft tells you to search for existing ideas and "add your voice to the existing feedback rather than creating a copy of it." It lists twelve statuses your idea could reach. On retention it says only that Microsoft won't delete this data "outside of our data retention policies."

What those policies are, you have to dig out of the portal itself. Users asked in 2023 why feedback disappears, and Microsoft answered:

Feedback portal post 'Why does some feedback disappear after fifteen months?', with an official Microsoft response: 'In order to adhere to privacy, security, and compliance regulations, feedback records older than 15 months age out of the Feedback web portal. However, feedback that has been moved into a Collection can still have these curated collections live on.'
The official Microsoft response, posted in the portal's own Feedback (web portal) forum three years ago. 8 votes.

The data agrees. On 16 November 2026, individual ideas in every forum start on 9 August 2025, fifteen months back. Apart from 8 stragglers, every older item still visible is a Collection. Advice to vote on the existing idea rather than post a new one only works if the existing idea is still there.

2023: the year somebody was curating with Collections

Let's look at what sticks. The post where Microsoft states the 15-month rule is a Collection, which is why it's still there three years later. Where the author's name should be, it says "Feedback collection," with an info icon:

'Feedback collection' shown as the author of the 15-month post, with its tooltip: 'Collections group together similar feedback so you can see how many users expressed this sentiment. In a collection, you can share your thoughts with us and other users in a common comment thread. The title of a collection describes how Microsoft has understood the sentiment of the collection. Please use the comments to let us know if you feel we've misunderstood it.'
The portal's own explanation, on the same post as the 15-month rule.

So a Collection has no customer behind it. Microsoft staff create it, merge similar ideas into it and title it. Otherwise it has the same votes, comments and status field as any other idea, and you can't make one yourself.

Collections are also where the answers are. They make up 6.3% of the ideas we could list, yet carry 77% of the statuses. 52% of Collections have a status other than "Open", against 1.04% of individual ideas. 42 of the 68 forums have no Collections at all, so in those forums nothing survives the 15 months.

Collections are the only escape hatch from the 15-month rule, but only while someone at Microsoft keeps merging new ideas into them. The portal's data shows, for each Collection, when an idea was last merged into it. For 94% of the 4 607 Collections, that was in 2023 or earlier. In the last 15 months, just 33 Collections took in a new idea, and 16 of those are in a single forum, Outlook (new). Across the rest of the portal, moving ideas to safety has all but stopped, so the 15-month rule applies to almost everything.

Collections by the year an idea was last merged into them2021: 90; 2022: 246; 2023: 3978; 2024: 194; 2025: 57; 2026: 4290202124620223 97820231942024572025422026

Collections by the year an idea was last merged into them, all 68 forums. Six forums with more than 5,000 ideas are sampled at 5,000 rows, so their counts are a floor.

The odds of being heard

1 in 96individual ideas has any status other than "Open": 721 of the 69 035 we looked at (1.04%). Most of the statuses on the portal belong to the old Collections.
1 in 5 753individual ideas has a written response that isn't an automated system message. That's 12 in total.
0 of 5 254Microsoft To Do ideas have been marked as anything at all. The to-do app's own to-do list has nothing done. It was the same story in April 2025.

Who's listening

Responsiveness is a product team feature that a portal can't automate. A few teams move ideas along: new Outlook and Edge mark a noticeable share of theirs. Windows 365 mostly marks them closed. Many others leave every single idea at "Open". Across every forum, 3 268 of 110 122 ideas (3.0%) carry any status. Here are the 15 biggest forums.

ForumIdeas nowCollectionsIndividual ideas with a status
XBOX Player Voice20 6731*2 of 4 999* (0.0%)
Microsoft Teams18 3231 244*6 of 3 756* (0.2%)
Outlook8 018815*111 of 4 185* (2.7%)
Excel7 590212*6 of 4 788* (0.1%)
Word6 434556*4 of 4 444* (0.1%)
Microsoft To Do5 2540*0 of 5 000* (0.0%)
Microsoft 365 Copilot app5 1750*22 of 5 000* (0.4%)
OneDrive4 35420 of 4 352 (0.0%)
SharePoint4 03611 of 4 035 (0.0%)
OneNote3 9391611 of 3 923 (0.3%)
Outlook (new)3 46430235 of 3 434 (6.8%)
Windows App2 313150 of 2 298 (0.0%)
PowerPoint1 964121 of 1 952 (0.1%)
Loop1 55972 of 1 552 (0.1%)
Microsoft Forms1 4821 0030 of 479 (0.0%)
Show the other forums
Planner1 15010 of 1 149 (0.0%)
Whiteboard1 149550 of 1 094 (0.0%)
Feedback (web portal)1 0822151 of 867 (0.1%)
Microsoft Intune94200 of 942 (0.0%)
Microsoft Edge911136157 of 775 (20.3%)
Exchange Online85601 of 856 (0.1%)
Microsoft Teams (free)845160 of 829 (0.0%)
Outlook.com7372021 of 535 (0.2%)
Microsoft Copilot for Service66600 of 666 (0.0%)
Bookings57500 of 575 (0.0%)
Microsoft Lists52600 of 526 (0.0%)
Bing50300 of 503 (0.0%)
Azure OpenAI Studio44500 of 445 (0.0%)
Copilot for Sales40710 of 403 (0.0%)
Microsoft Access362101 of 350 (0.3%)
Microsoft Rewards34900 of 349 (0.0%)
Clipchamp289352 of 253 (0.8%)
Communication Compliance28000 of 280 (0.0%)
Windows 365 Cloud PC2722117 of 270 (43.3%)
Microsoft Graph27202 of 272 (0.7%)
Microsoft 365 Admin Center – Copilot Agent Management25800 of 258 (0.0%)
Microsoft Defender XDR25402 of 254 (0.8%)
Data Loss Prevention23700 of 237 (0.0%)
Visio19300 of 193 (0.0%)
Microsoft Viva Engage18800 of 188 (0.0%)
Microsoft Education Apps16602 of 166 (1.2%)
Microsoft Information Protection16430 of 161 (0.0%)
Microsoft Configuration Manager14550 of 140 (0.0%)
Data Lifecycle and Records Management11600 of 116 (0.0%)
Windows Autopatch11500 of 115 (0.0%)
Launcher10800 of 108 (0.0%)
Bing IME10500 of 105 (0.0%)
Microsoft Family Safety9801 of 98 (1.0%)
Microsoft 365 Lighthouse8900 of 89 (0.0%)
Exchange Server7700 of 77 (0.0%)
Skype7400 of 74 (0.0%)
Insider Risk Management6600 of 66 (0.0%)
Project6500 of 65 (0.0%)
Microsoft Edge Game Assist59033 of 58 (56.9%)
Microsoft Create5400 of 54 (0.0%)
Calendar Companion4600 of 45 (0.0%)
Microsoft Viva Insights3700 of 37 (0.0%)
Microsoft Stream36120 of 24 (0.0%)
Microsoft Editor Browser Extension3300 of 33 (0.0%)
Sway3200 of 32 (0.0%)
Microsoft Viva Connections2500 of 25 (0.0%)
Microsoft Viva Amplify2100 of 21 (0.0%)
Microsoft Viva Learning1700 of 17 (0.0%)
Enterprise Learner Assist1400 of 13 (0.0%)
eDiscovery1100 of 10 (0.0%)
Microsoft Viva Glint1000 of 9 (0.0%)
Hugging Face on Microsoft Foundry800 of 7 (0.0%)
Microsoft Viva Goals500 of 4 (0.0%)

* Forum has more than 5,000 ideas. The portal's API returns at most 5,000 rows, so these columns come from a 5,000-row sample. Totals come from the forum's own counter. Download: forums.csv.

Expiring soon

About 6 380 ideas reach the 15-month mark in the next 30 days, carrying roughly 37 700 votes between them. These are the most-voted of the ideas due to go in the next 60 days. Voting won't save them. Only curation does.

Even the insiders get caught out

The 30-year MS veteran

David E. Craig has worked at Microsoft since 1994, by his own account. In October 2024 he hit a wall: POST /planner/tasks returns 403 on Planner Premium plans while reads work fine. He documented it on Microsoft Q&A, then filed it on the Feedback portal, where it gathered roughly 300 votes. When it vanished, the follow-up idea he posted said it had been "deleted with NO FEEDBACK". In practice, it had just expired.

Why not just ping someone internally? His answer in his blog comments:

"I do have some contacts and can find my way to the right people, but I am also avoiding a conflict of interest. The Planner issue is one of those. I have to let it play out on the global stage and let the issue present itself organically."

The 34 missing MVP suggestions

Daniel Pineault, a long-time Microsoft Access MVP, went through 34 of his own suggestions in early 2026. Every one of them was gone. His follow-up was titled "The Purge Is Complete!"

He was right about the effect and wrong only about the intent. It wasn't a purge. It's a scheduled job that has apparently been running for years, without a word about it in the documentation he'd naturally check.

So what do you do with your next idea?

Treat the portal as a mailbox, not an archive. Keep your own copy of the text, the link and the vote count. If the issue matters past 15 months, link to it from somewhere that doesn't forget: a Q&A thread, a community post, your own blog. When an idea of yours gets close to its date and still matters, the only documented way to keep it is a Collection. Which aren't apparently used anymore.

Not every Microsoft feedback site works like this. The Power Platform ideas sites run on separate environments and appear to keep older ideas around. The 15-month rule belongs to Microsoft's main Feedback portal.

Meet the human in the loop

This page was prompted into existence by me, Jukka Niiranen, using Claude Code. Perspectives.plus is where I do my organic writing on Microsoft business applications, Power Platform and Copilot: licensing changes, product decisions and the gap between what's announced and what you can actually use. Independent analysis, with the evidence attached.

The companion article, Your feedback, deleted, explores what happens when customer feedback disappears—and asks readers whether their own submissions have received a response.

Your feedback, deleted →

Subscribe to Perspectives

Jukka Niiranen / 20+ years in Microsoft business applications

Jukka Niiranen
How these numbers were made

All figures come from the public Feedback portal on 16 November 2026, read through the same JSON endpoints the portal's own web page uses, as an anonymous visitor. Nothing was posted, voted or signed in.

  • Idea totals come from each forum's own counter. Status counts come from status-filtered queries.
  • The portal's API returns at most 5,000 rows per forum, so forums above that (XBOX Player Voice, Microsoft Teams, Outlook, Excel, Word, Microsoft To Do, Microsoft 365 Copilot app) are sampled at 5,000 rows. Their Collection and individual-idea figures are from that sample.
  • "Individual idea" means anything that isn't a Collection. "With a status" means any status other than "Open".
  • Expiry dates are the posting date plus 15 calendar months. On 16 November 2026 the oldest surviving individual idea was from 9 August 2025, so the job seems to run within a few days of the 15-month mark. 8 older individual ideas have somehow survived out of roughly 69,000. Every system has its exceptions. Per-day and 30-day figures are estimates scaled up for the sampled forums.
  • The comparison with 2025 comes from Microsoft's feedback maze (April 2025), whose figures were also a 15-month window plus Collections, though we didn't know that then.

Corrections are welcome by email or on LinkedIn.